Intel shareholder lawsuit targets executives over PC sales slump

Akhil Ponnada
Akhil Ponnada is the founder and editor of FrontWord. He covers artificial intelligence, chips and infrastructure, consumer technology, cybersecurity and the business of tech.
5 Min Read
Image: Wccftech

An Intel shareholder lawsuit filed in federal court in San Jose, California, accuses the chipmaker and its top executives of concealing a prolonged slump in personal computer sales, triggering a 29% single-day stock collapse on 30 October. The proposed class action claims the company misled investors about deteriorating demand before issuing disappointing financial forecasts.

Allegations of hidden inventory and falling demand

The lawsuit was filed on Friday by Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd on behalf of investors who bought Intel common shares between 23 July and 29 October. It names Intel, chief executive Lip-Bu Tan, and chief financial officer David Zinsner as defendants.

According to reporting by BBC News, the complaint claims Intel made statements that failed to disclose the drop in PC chip demand and the true impact of its data centre projects. The legal filing alleges that these omissions artificially inflated the company’s share price and delayed warnings to shareholders.

Investors allege that Intel leaders concealed an inventory glut and weakening computer sales to keep the share price steady while raising fresh capital. In mid-August, Intel sold $23 billion in stock to help fund the expansion of a new facility for its contract chip manufacturing arm, Wccftech reported.

The complaint argues that executives had clear motivation and opportunity to hold back the negative disclosures until after completing the capital raise. According to lawsuit details cited by Reuters, deteriorating PC sales and excess inventory outweighed any financial gains that Intel achieved from data centre construction and the broader artificial intelligence market.

The October earnings forecast and market plunge

The financial problems surfaced publicly on 29 October, when the processor maker published revenue and profit projections for its fourth quarter. Intel warned of weaker-than-expected earnings and cautioned investors that the slump across the personal computer market would extend further.

At the same time, Intel revealed that sales of its computer hardware had dropped sharply during the three months ending in September. That disclosure contradicted earlier suggestions from company management that consumer hardware demand was beginning to improve.

The lawsuit states that depressed demand for personal computer sales caused a dramatic slowdown in quarterly earnings. The shortfall represented a drop of 9%, or about $800 million, cutting Intel’s quarterly earnings to $8.1 billion.

The market reaction on Wall Street was swift. On 30 October, Intel shares plunged by nearly 29% in a single day, erasing tens of billions of dollars off its market valuation. Some calculations reported by Reuters placed the single-day market value wipeout at $140 billion.

Over the past month, Intel shares had fallen 37.5% overall. Despite the sharp decline following the forecast, the company’s shares remained up by 51% across the calendar year.

Manufacturing expansion and supply bottlenecks

Intel has poured heavy investments into its manufacturing operations to meet surging demand for artificial intelligence computing. However, expanding fabrication capacity has run into operational and market difficulties.

As more semiconductors were channelled towards data centres, chips for PCs and other electronics became more expensive. Ongoing supply disruptions also limited Intel’s ability to capitalise on the demand for data centre processors.

At the same time, climbing dynamic random-access memory prices drove up retail costs for desktop and laptop computers, discouraging consumer purchases and compounding the slump in PC demand.

During the October earnings briefing, Tan acknowledged that manufacturing bottlenecks, an “unprecedented memory crunch” and softness in the PC market weighed heavily on company performance.

“We need to address these challenges with urgency,” Tan said during the call with analysts.

The proposed class action seeks unspecified damages on behalf of shareholders who bought Intel common stock between 23 July and 29 October.

The BBC contacted Intel for comment following the filing of the lawsuit in California.

Follow:
Akhil Ponnada is the founder and editor of FrontWord. He covers artificial intelligence, chips and infrastructure, consumer technology, cybersecurity and the business of tech.